I was wondering how critical you are when you review a book?
I did a review
yesterday and gave it a two out of five. Why? Well, the story was okay...but just okay. I wouldn't have rated it over a three, but I gave it a two because I factored in errors in grammar and punctuation. I expect those things in review copies but I just couldn't bring myself to suggest readers buy the book since these flaws were in the finished product.
Do you consider things like that in your reviews or do you just base the review on the story itself?