Reciprocal Author Reviews – Unethical credibility damagers or good business?

The concept of author’s trading reviews is somewhat troubling for me.  Even if unspoken or stated otherwise, does it create an expectation of “I’ll give you five stars and you give me five?”  Won’t the perception of readers that this is “going on” hurt the credibility of the participants?

Now don’t get me wrong.  I think it is good that authors and writers are willing to do reviews.  Why shouldn’t those so intimately involved in the profession participate in reviewing others’ books?   The potential problem arises when reviews are “traded.”

I think the correct policy to follow may be a willingness to review others’ books but not of authors who have reviewed your work.   The problem is that there is a shortage of reviewers for most genres.  So how do we find a happy middle ground where everyone involved is served.  What do you think?

Views: 127

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I think the middle would be to make your work available to the author especially as a review copy, that way the person hasn't got to worry about cost. And a review can be done a lot quicker. Is that a good idea, I am new to this so I am not sure.

I don't know. I would think an author would prefer someone who is an editor or who normally reviews books to review their work. I can see how there might be a conflict of interest. As a book blogger and reviewer myself, we kind of all are on the honors policy, aren't we? I mean, you trust that I am giving a fair review and readers are trusting that I am honest. Right?

You are right.  It is less likely though that a conflict of interest will occur between author and a  reviewer / blogger than between two authors who are "trading reviews."

Ah, yes - the NYT model.

Unethical, not credible and yet... good business.

Go figure.

We get to decide if we are going to engage in unethical practices.  I am very uncomfortable with the idea of authors "trading reviews." 

I don't think it's something you "decide", it's more like being afraid of payback.

To lead a life of fear is to give up our freedom.

I think we as bloggers need to realize that when we review someones book that we need to be truthful about the book. If your a writer then your hoping that the person or persons will be truthful. I would want someone that's willing to read it, tell the truth, then say wither its worth reading. I don't really read what people here have written yet, I would feel sort of unconfertable writing a review where I didn't like the book. I know that its hard to get those then you get critacism about your review. I've heard of some people getting mad because they didn't like what you said. 

Being that I haven't finished writing my own book. I really do believe that I'll let an editor review it first and hope for publication then, I'll let the book bloggers and newspapers go for it. That just how I feel.

I agree that being truthful is always the best policy.  The truth is no matter how good your book is it won't be liked by everyone.  If the book is poorly written you can learn a lot from constructive criticism.   

I've read a few samples of books that have glowing reviews but the grammar, content, story was so awful that I immediately stopped reading.  It made me wonder where all of those great reviews came from - hmmm....   

I've been contacted by other authors and asked to review their books - I make my review policy clear:  If I don't like it (meaning it is awful or difficult to read) then I won't review it.  There's enough negativity out there without me adding to the pile.  If I love it or even like it - I review it honestly on Amazon and on my blog. I never ask for a reciprocal review because I would feel as if I were somehow implying that they should abide by my policy or give my book a good review.  I think in the end credibility and reputation suffer because of "innacurate" reviews.  As a result of my experiences, I don't pay much attention to reviews; I sample books and if I like the sample then I buy the book. 

It sounds like you are handling the reviews well !


Need help?




Guest Post: The In’s and Out’s of NetGalley

Guest Post: The In’s and Out’s of NetGalley I’m happy to welcome Lili, Children’s Publicity Intern at Bloomsbury USA and a blogger, as our guest writer today. Lili has been documenting her internship experiences in publishing in her Intern Diaries series and recently reflected on the NetGalley approval process from a publisher’s point of view. […]

Top Ten UK Books… coming in April 2015

Every month, we get together to come up with a top-ten list of the UK titles we’re most looking forward to – and this month we’re focusing on books published in April 2015. It’s an eclectic mix this month, with two SF titles – Poseidon’s Wake and The Rebirths of Tao – which I would highly […]

March edition

The American Booksellers Association has announced the selections for the March Indie Next list, drawn from the recommendations of indie booksellers throughout the US. You can request many of these titles on NetGalley right now, and view more information on the ABA site.  If you are a bookseller, you can nominate titles for the Indie […]

© 2015   Created by Tarah Theoret.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service