I've been thinking a lot about this topic and posted about it recently, but...

What makes a good book review, in your opinion?

Views: 2150

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I like to get a very general idea what the book is about, and get a feel for what impact it had on the reader. Was it funny? Did it make you cry? What issues did it make you think about? That sort of thing.
I like to see three things in a book review.

1) The reviewer's overall assessment in qualitative terms
2) An idea of the storyline, genre and characters
3) A recommendation for the type of readers that would enjoy the book.

These three things help me decide If I would enjoy a book or not.
Book reviews should tell the reader enough about the book to let them know if it's the kind of book they might enjoy or get something out of or whether they ought to avoid it. They shouldn't give stars or best stamps because reading is a very personal thing. Whether we love or hate a book shouldn't be in the review - unless you state it's a personal response.
So, a book review should give basic plot, something about style, structure, characterisation, maybe a quotation (not too lengthy) to give an idea of the narrative and should give a summation of whether it successfully achieves what it sets out to do.
A book is what it is, that's what ought to be judged.
A book review is not a synopsis. I've read reviews that precluded my need to read the book because the reviewer told all the juicy highlights leaving nothing to be discovered. A review should be composed of some remarks about the authors style, character development, and the emotional/intellectual impact of the book on the reviewer.
I agree.
I think they should be (not too short), but to the point. I also love it to be less professional. I want to feel like I have just been told by one of my friends that this book rocked. (Spelling and grammer are still important!)
A good book review give a glimpse of the story without giving away too much. I like when the reviewer tells me if they liked it. If the reviewer is excited about the book and it sounds like a plot I would like I am more likely to read it.
I thinks it's my passion for books and picking the right book to review makes me feel like I am in Heaven and I want to let evry body knows about the book by reviewing it.
I would include a quote or two from the book or an interview with the author to give the reader a small taste of the work. I think detail like that helps a book review but in order for it to be a truly useful review the writer needs to have an informed opinion to share with readers. Did they like the book, why or why not should be the central question the review answers.
A good review does not give away the book, but instead lets those reading the review how you, as the reader felt over all. I look strongly into character development and like to have a good sense of who they are not only physically so I can get a clear picture of them in my head - but also who they are as people. I want to know if a character struggles with a choice or has fear, or strong beliefs. Is the character wimpy? Then I want to sense and feel their weakness. Is the character strong and determined? Then I want to battle right along side them - or at least feel as though I have.

In a review - I look for a good feel of what sort of style the author writes in. Does it reminder you of another author? Then I want to know. Is the author unique in his/her writing style? That's a huge plus as too often we get trapped in a cookie cutter style of read....

I agree with some of the other comments here.... share how the book made you feel without giving the book away. Dont make it overly long and do not give too much away.

I like my reviews because they seem to convey exactly what I want to the potential reader, regardless if they may or may not like the subject matter or content.


Need help?




Guest Post: The In’s and Out’s of NetGalley

Guest Post: The In’s and Out’s of NetGalley I’m happy to welcome Lili, Children’s Publicity Intern at Bloomsbury USA and a blogger, as our guest writer today. Lili has been documenting her internship experiences in publishing in her Intern Diaries series and recently reflected on the NetGalley approval process from a publisher’s point of view. […]

Top Ten UK Books… coming in April 2015

Every month, we get together to come up with a top-ten list of the UK titles we’re most looking forward to – and this month we’re focusing on books published in April 2015. It’s an eclectic mix this month, with two SF titles – Poseidon’s Wake and The Rebirths of Tao – which I would highly […]

March edition

The American Booksellers Association has announced the selections for the March Indie Next list, drawn from the recommendations of indie booksellers throughout the US. You can request many of these titles on NetGalley right now, and view more information on the ABA site.  If you are a bookseller, you can nominate titles for the Indie […]

© 2015   Created by Tarah Theoret.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service